Misled from the Metaphor: The trouble out-of Ingrained Analogy
I am in debt to help you Jeffrey Dunn and you may Tamara Beauboeuf due to their quick and you will insightful comments with the an earlier write and Pierre Boulos for the dialogue regarding the historical examples. And i am grateful on the unknown reviewers, which provided much needed recommendations and you will comments.
Conceptual
Nancy Leys Stepan’s historical investigation of your own analogical need used in nineteenth century search to the individual adaptation features a fascinating ability out of scientific commentary: metaphors imported from huge community normally adversely effect medical practice. Within report, We think about the jobs of analogical reasoning during the medical behavior and you can demonstrated how it is misguide the fresh experts depending on they. One of the ways, the difficulty away from instilled analogy, performance in the event that correspondences off an effective metaphor getting established on brains out-of researchers. Early in the day options, supplied by Turbayne (1971) and you may Recker (2004, 2010), lack the info to handle the difficulty. Hence, We propose introducing unique feedback regarding relevant outsiders as a way in order to decrease the effectiveness of scientific metaphors so you can mislead. (suite…)